Everett Cash Mutual Insurance Company Acquires American Reliable’s Farm, Ranch, and Equine Business

August 9, 2022

Global Indemnity Group, LLC , announced today that American Reliable Insurance Company (“ARIC”), a GBLI subsidiary, completed the disposition of ARIC’s Farm, Ranch, and Equine book of renewal business to Everett Cash Mutual. GBLI also announced that it agreed to sell ARIC to Everett Cash Mutual (ECM), which, subject to regulatory approvals and customary transactional conditions, is expected to close in or before the first quarter of 2023. GBLI and ECM anticipate that the renewal rights and acquisition transactions will further enhance ARIC’s provision of products and services to both ARIC’s policyholders and to ARIC’s agency partners.

In aggregate GBLI will receive approximately $85 million, including the release of capital currently supporting ARIC’s operations (over the course of the next 12 months). GBLI will receive $30 million for the sale of renewal rights and will receive an amount equal to surplus when ARIC is sold. Until ECM acquires American Reliable, ECM will be providing GBLI with 100% quota share reinsurance in respect of policies subject to the renewal rights agreement with ECM

GBLI exited ARIC’s Manufactured Homes and Dwellings business in the fourth quarter of 2021, which was comparable in size to ARIC’s Farm, Ranch, & Equine business and generated comparable proceeds to GBLI upon its disposition.

Randy Shaw, CEO and President of ECM, commented: “Everett Cash Mutual Insurance Co., founded in 1913, is committed to serving the insurance needs of the agricultural community.” Shaw added that “ECM’s acquisition of ARIC will shift ECM from a regional carrier to a national provider with combined gross written premium approaching $200 million. We look forward to engaging with American Reliable employees and agents in the coming days.”

David Charlton, Chief Executive Officer of GLBI, commented: “GBLI will be working closely with ECM to assure that the renewal rights and acquisition transactions will be seamless for ARIC policyholders and ARIC’s agent partners. In that regard, we encourage ARIC’s agents to partner with ECM, who is a carrier dedicated to processing Farm, Ranch, & Equine insurance.” Charlton added that, “These transactions will also enable GBLI to further sharpen its focus on the company’s core small and middle market commercial specialty casualty businesses”.

Merger & Acquisition Services Inc. served as the financial advisor to Global Indemnity Group, LLC.

About Global Indemnity Group, LLC.

Global Indemnity Group, LLC (NYSE:GBLI), through its several direct and indirect wholly owned subsidiary insurance companies, provides both admitted and non-admitted specialty property and casualty insurance coverages and individual policyholder coverages in the United States, as well as reinsurance worldwide. Global Indemnity Group, LLC’s four primary business units are:

  • Small to Middle Market Commercial Business
  • Commercial Specialty Business
  • Programs
  • Reinsurance

About Everett Cash Mutual

Founded in 1913, Everett Cash Mutual Insurance Co. is a property/casualty mutual insurer focused on serving the farm and agri-business sector. ECM provides state of the art products and technology to support its marketing territory. ECM is rated A “Excellent” by A.M. Best

About Merger & Acquisition Services, Inc.
Merger & Acquisition Services, Inc. is a specialist advisory and financial services Firm to the insurance and reinsurance industry, with offices in New York, Connecticut, Georgia & Cayman Islands. Founded in 1999, the Firm and its affiliates provides investment banking and insurance consulting services globally, including; merger & acquisition advisory capital raising, valuations, program placement/fronting, and reinsurance advisory. Merger & Acquisition Capital Services, LLC., a registered broker-dealer and member FINRA / SIPC, is an affiliate of Merger & Acquisition Services, Inc.

To learn more about Merger & Acquisition Services, visit https://maservices.com.


Investment banking services and all securities are offered in the United States by and through Merger & Acquisition Capital Services, LLC, a US registered broker-dealer and member FINRA/SIPC. Merger & Acquisition Services, Inc., M&A International LTD & M&A International Corporation U.A. do not underwrite securities, nor advise on, nor effect transactions in securities for the account of others.